November 19: a dickens sandwich

I have been reading a bit. I read Our Mutual Friend by Dickens, followed by Klara and the Sun by Ishiguru and now I’m back on Dickens with The Mystery of Edwin Drood, his last and unfinished novel. When you have a Dickens sandwich like that, particularly when on the sandwich there is a small pice of salad leaf, the differences between styles are flagrant.

Dickens, at this stage of his career (the end) had, it seems to me, experienced a sharp loss in confidence in his own writing. This s my opinion. You will not find it anywhere else. Since Great Expectations he had not written a novel for four years and spent his time performing in plays or doing readings from earlier novels. Our Mutual friend is terrific in its overall reach and the ideas behind the characters, but there are many pages of over-extended metaphors and over-elaborate rhetoric, as if he is trying too hard to reconnect with his former instincts.. A lot of this stuff you could just throw away. Same in a way for Edwin Drood where there is so much tiresome religious allusion. The directness of Great Expectations has been lost . Of course, Dickens, being so generous and risk-taking with his material, makes up for it.

Ishiguru, meanwhile, is good because of what he does not put in. It is the writing of a diplomat. Bleak, riskless, mostly humourless (only drole in the moments where you have to guess at an elision or an unspoken beat). It is like a civil servant drafting a flawless document. Unlike Dickens, there is nothing yon need throw away. Very much a modern writer. Not much reaching out; no belly-laughs. In many ways, we are less rich because of it. It is a revealing filling to place in the Dickens sandwich.

September 20: me at my most sophisticated

On the TV channel SkyArts I read a little trailer for a documentary. It was a biographical programme about the famous and influential 20th Century poet T. S. Eliot. It said something like: The fascinating story of the life of T.S. Eliot, the man responsible for the poems that would inspire the Broadway musical Cats. I suppose they thought this would get more viewers in than the man who wrote the seminal modernist poems The Wasteland and Four Quartets. Barnard Castle was built during the Norman conquest and was was owned by the Duke of Gloucester, later Richard III. It was also, of course, the day trip venue of Dominic Cummings, advisor to Boris Jonson during the Covid period. Andre Previn, despite having spent his life devoted to Classical music as both a conductor and a composer, seems to be mostly remembered for his appearance on The Morecombe and Wise Show.

You cannot know how posterity will channel you or how others will see you. Of course, circumstances constantly force you to behave in a way suitable to the moment and away from your natural instincts and inclinations. Jobs push you away from yourself, make you act on behalf of the company you work for or more in keeping with your job title rather than your personality. It is a miracle that we ever emerge unscathed from the combat with the world. This act of shifting away from yourself for the sake of the circumstance is perhaps the most sophisticated act we have to perform as an individual. I consider myself fortunate that it is rare that I have to abandon myself to represent some other entity. Many people – mostly people with fancy jobs – just drift away, and when, later in life perhaps, they try and pick up that old lost self, they are not quite sure what it is thay are holding in their hands anymore. As I say, I’m lucky. The closest I get to abandoning my self is when I am just nodding along and pretending to listen to a dull interlocutor. That’s probably when I’m at my most sophisticated.

peoplearerubbish.com