I have been reading a bit. I read Our Mutual Friend by Dickens, followed by Klara and the Sun by Ishiguru and now I’m back on Dickens with The Mystery of Edwin Drood, his last and unfinished novel. When you have a Dickens sandwich like that, particularly when on the sandwich there is a small pice of salad leaf, the differences between styles are flagrant.
Dickens, at this stage of his career (the end) had, it seems to me, experienced a sharp loss in confidence in his own writing. This s my opinion. You will not find it anywhere else. Since Great Expectations he had not written a novel for four years and spent his time performing in plays or doing readings from earlier novels. Our Mutual friend is terrific in its overall reach and the ideas behind the characters, but there are many pages of over-extended metaphors and over-elaborate rhetoric, as if he is trying too hard to reconnect with his former instincts.. A lot of this stuff you could just throw away. Same in a way for Edwin Drood where there is so much tiresome religious allusion. The directness of Great Expectations has been lost . Of course, Dickens, being so generous and risk-taking with his material, makes up for it.
Ishiguru, meanwhile, is good because of what he does not put in. It is the writing of a diplomat. Bleak, riskless, mostly humourless (only drole in the moments where you have to guess at an elision or an unspoken beat). It is like a civil servant drafting a flawless document. Unlike Dickens, there is nothing yon need throw away. Very much a modern writer. Not much reaching out; no belly-laughs. In many ways, we are less rich because of it. It is a revealing filling to place in the Dickens sandwich.